Wednesday, April 13, 2016

Review: A Madness So Discreet – Mindy McGinnis

A Madness So Discreet – Mindy McGinnis

Grace Mae knows madness. 
She keeps it locked away, along with her voice, trapped deep inside a brilliant mind that cannot forget horrific family secrets. Those secrets, along with the bulge in her belly, land her in a Boston insane asylum. 
When her voice returns in a burst of violence, Grace is banished to the dark cellars, where her mind is discovered by a visiting doctor who dabbles in the new study of criminal psychology. With her keen eyes and sharp memory, Grace will make the perfect assistant at crime scenes. Escaping from Boston to the safety of an ethical Ohio asylum, Grace finds friendship and hope, hints of a life she should have had. But gruesome nights bring Grace and the doctor into the circle of a killer who stalks young women. Grace, continuing to operate under the cloak of madness, must hunt a murderer while she confronts the demons in her own past.

Review: First, I need to profess my love for that cover. It definitely gave me a “Shut up and take my money moment.” It’s beautiful in a messed-up way.

Mindy McGinnis’s other book, Not A Drop To Drink, was one of my favorite books that I read in 2015. When I heard about this one, I knew that I needed to give it a try. Luckily, it’s pretty good.

This novel is set in the 1800s and follows a woman, Grace Mae, who is committed to an insane asylum for being an aristocrat with loose morals. Basically, her family sent her to an asylum because she’s pregnant and unmarried, and they don’t want the public to know. In the asylum, Grace meets a doctor who is studying criminal psychology. The doctor notices Grace’s intelligence and great memory, so he decides to make her his assistant. They work together to stop a serial killer who is murdering young girls.

I saw this book marketed as a historical thriller, but I’m not sure if that’s a good way to describe it. The pacing is very slow for a thriller, but it’s an entertaining historical novel. I love that it gives off vibes of classic horror and detective stories. Grace’s life in the asylum is so brutal that she begs for a lobotomy. Most of the doctors and nurses offer no help and treat the patients like animals. Grace spends most of her time locked in a cell until she meets a doctor who sees her potential. It’s depressing, but historically accurate. Insane asylums were not pleasant places.

The characters are the best part of this book. Even the ones deemed “sane” are unpredictable and morally gray. The reader has to question what “sane” and “insane” mean because many of the characters blur the lines. These characters are wicked-smart. They don’t always make the most ethical choices. Their dialogue is snappy. Even though the story is depressing, there were times where I laughed at the characters’ conversations. If you’re interested in novels with brilliant dialogue, check this one out.

I did have trouble with some parts of the book. First, the plot sometimes feels like it isn’t going anywhere. It’s just floundering. The middle is especially slow. I wish the characters had felt more urgency to catch the murderer because the slowest parts occur while they are sitting around, discussing the crimes.

I also think that some parts of the story work out a little too conveniently. I don’t want to give away spoilers, but a few situations—especially at the end—are solved a little too easily for me to believe.

I didn’t love everything about this book, but I did love what it teaches the reader about the history of mental health care. “Sane” and “insane” are often just labels. They can be subjective, and their meanings can change as society changes. In this book, all of the characters are a little crazy, even the ones who don’t live in the asylum.    



  1. I actually started listening to the audiobook awhile ago, but stopped pretty quickly because it was slow and I was just in the mood for something quicker. I never felt the horror vibe, but I didn't give it much of a chance... I do think I might give this another try! I'm glad you enjoyed it even if it wasn't perfect.

    Tracy @ Cornerfolds

    1. It was slower than I would have liked, but I thought the characters and premise were pretty cool.

      Aj @ Read All The Things!

  2. Oh nice! I still need to read this one. And Mindy's second book to her first duology! Oh wow, that's mindboggling! LOL! Glad to hear that this one was enjoyable, if a tad slow. Nice review!

  3. I loved this book! Specially the exploration of all things mad, and the portrayal of the people who resided in the asylums. And you're right the cover is just breathtaking!

  4. I agree SO much with everything you have said. I didn't know it was being touted as a thriller, and you're right, it really isn't. But I did really like it! I think there were some slow parts, but it was SO unique- I don't think there is a single thing like it in YA- and I LOVED the history of mental health! You could actually see the landscape changing ever so slightly, it was fabulous. Great review, I am so glad you enjoyed it!

  5. I'm so intrigued about this book! I took a class on history of psychiatry once and it's both horrifying and fascinating, so I love what you've said about it being historically accurate. Thanks for sharing this review!