Monday, July 18, 2016

Review: Forgive Me, Leonard Peacock – Matthew Quick


Forgive Me, Leonard Peacock – Matthew Quick


Today is Leonard Peacock’s birthday. It is also the day he hides a gun in his backpack. Because today is the day he will kill his former best friend, and then himself, with his grandfather’s P-38 pistol. 
But first he must say goodbye to the four people who matter most to him: his Humphrey Bogart-obsessed next-door neighbor, Walt; his classmate, Baback, a violin virtuoso; Lauren, the Christian homeschooler he has a crush on; and Herr Silverman, who teaches the high school’s class on the Holocaust. Speaking to each in turn, Leonard slowly reveals his secrets as the hours tick by and the moment of truth approaches.


Review: I have book review déjà vu. I feel like I just read (and kind of hated) this book about a week ago. There was a point in Forgive Me, Leonard Peacock (the bottom of page 69, actually) where I threw the book down and thought, Not this AGAIN! NO NO NO NO! I just don’t understand the appeal of this “deep, dark secret” mental illness plot.

I was interested in this book because it was described to me as part dystopia, part high school contemporary. That sounds pretty cool, right? What’s more dystopian than a modern-day high school?

On Leonard’s eighteenth birthday, he plans to kill his former best friend and then himself. We follow him through his school day as he says goodbye to his few friends and works up the courage to carry out his plan. Sprinkled throughout the book are letters that Leonard writes to himself from his ideal future. In his imagination, the future is a post-apocalyptic world that is mostly covered by water. He lives in a lighthouse with his wife and daughter and is very happy.

The letters are my favorite part of the book. The explanation for them comes far too late, so they’re a little jarring to read, but they’re unique. They show a lot about Leonard’s character. Not many people would say that their ideal future is a world where pretty much everybody is dead. The upbeat tone of the letters also provides relief from Leonard’s self-obsessed attitude.

“I feel like I’m broken—like I don’t fit together anymore. Like there’s no more room for me in the world or something. Like I’ve overstayed my welcome here on Earth, and everyone’s trying to give me hints about that constantly. Like I should just check out.” – Forgive Me, Leonard Peacock
 
“we can simultaneously be human and monster—that both of those possibilities are in all of us.” – Forgive Me, Leonard Peacock

Leonard is hiding a secret from the reader. His former best friend, Asher, did something awful to him. I’ve seen this same plot in a lot of other “mental illness” books, and I’m not a fan. I’m just going to copy my review for one of the other books, change the character names, and paste it here. You know that a plotline is overdone when the same review works for multiple books.

[Start copy/paste.]

On one hand, I know that this is an extremely important book. Young adult stories about trauma and illness are necessary because (unfortunately) many young readers have had trauma and/or mental illness in their lives. Everyone deserves to see themselves in a book.

On the other hand, I found this novel to be really, really predictable. Leonard has a deep, dark, traumatic secret that he’s hiding from everybody. It’s the exact same deep, dark, traumatic secret that a ton of other YA protagonists are hiding. I feel like I’ve read this book before. Many, many times. I could see his secret coming from a thousand miles away. Since I figured out his secret relatively early, I had to sit through 100+ pages of tedious angst while I waited for him to tell me what I already knew. If I hadn’t been reading this book for a class, I wouldn’t have finished it. Predictable books frustrate me.

[End copy/paste.]

I struggled to connect with every character in this book. A lot of them feel like stereotypes. There’s the depressed teen, the quirky old man, the absentee parents, the hero teacher. Leonard’s plan to kill Asher and commit suicide never seems all that threatening, and my brain was always several steps ahead of the plot. Maybe I need to give up on “mental illness” books because this one didn’t do much that I haven’t seen before.

I know this review sounds pretty negative. This isn’t a horrible book. I can see why it has so many positive reviews. It’s well-written and very quick to read. Up until page 69, when I figured out what Asher did to Leonard, I was intrigued by the story. It has an excellent message for teens who are struggling through high school. But, overall, this novel just isn’t unique enough for me.

“‘I can tell you get it—you're different. And I know how hard being different can be. But I also know how powerful a weapon being different can be. How the world needs such weapons. Gandhi was different. All great people are. And unique people such as you and me need to seek out other unique people who understand—so we don't get too lonely and end up where you did tonight.’” – Forgive Me, Leonard Peacock









Sunday, July 17, 2016

The Sunday Post #56


The Sunday Post is hosted by The Caffeinated Book Reviewer. It’s a chance to recap the past week, talk about next week, and share news. It’s Monday, What Are You Reading? is hosted by Book Date. I get to tell you what I’ve read recently.



On The Blog Last Week






On The Blog This Week


  • On Monday I review Forgive Me, Leonard Peacock by Matthew Quick.
  • On Tuesday I show you some books set outside the USA.
  • On Wednesday I review All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr.
  • On Thursday I do The Diverse Books Tag.




In My Blogging Life


The comments on Why Diverse Books Matter To Me have been really interesting. Go check it out if you haven’t yet.

Is anyone else’s Bloglovin’ feed broken? I follow about 900 blogs, but it only shows me like, 8 posts. This isn’t cool!




In My Reading Life


I read a ton last week. I finished All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr. Then I read Nimona by Noelle Stevenson, All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque, and She is Not Invisible by Marcus Sedgwick. Right now, I’m reading I’ll Meet You There by Heather Demetrios.







In The Rest Of My Life


Five things that made me happy last week:

  1. Top Ten Tuesday. I liked learning random things about all my Internet friends.
  2. My discussion post. I know I already mentioned it twice, but I had that post saved as a draft for months. I’m glad I actually finished it.
  3. I spent some time outside playing with the settings on my camera.
  4. While taking pictures, I discovered that there’s a giant toad living under my deck. It gave me something to take pictures of.
  5. So much reading.





I hope you had a great week! See you around the blogosphere!











Thursday, July 14, 2016

Discussion: Why Diverse Books Matter To Me

Feed Your Fiction Addiction and It Starts At Midnight host the 2016 Discussion Challenge.

Why Diverse Books Matter To Me


If you met me, the word “diverse” probably would not come to mind. I’m a straight, able-bodied, white, twenty-something woman who was raised in a middleclass, nonreligious household. Like many Americans, I’m the product of European immigrants who came to the US in the 1800-1900s. I speak fluent English with a General American accent. My first name is an English name and is one of the most common first names for US-born girls in my generation. I graduated from high school on time and have college degrees. When I enter a public place in my hometown, I can guarantee that the majority of the people there will look, sound, think, and act a lot like me.




As a young child, I never had a problem “finding myself” in a book. Most of the fictional characters I read about were white, middleclass kids like me. It was the same with movies and TV shows. I saw myself everywhere, and I never questioned why everybody in the media was so much like me. The lack of diversity never crossed my child-mind.





I first became aware of readers' desire for more diversity in books when I was studying publishing at a university in 2013. I started researching statistics about the lack of non-white main characters in children’s literature. It actually shocked me how little diversity could be found in children’s books. I thought I should help do something about it. I bought books about non-straight, non-white, non-middleclass characters and shared them with other children’s lit aficionados. I supported the diverse books movement, but I mostly felt like I was cheerleading from the sidelines because I’m not a part of any underrepresented group. As far as I know, the lack of diversity in children's books never impacted me personally. I didn’t even notice it when I was a kid because I was part of the majority group.

Diversity in books became slightly more personal for me in 2015. I posted a review of Becky Albertalli’s LGBT book Simon vs The Homo Sapiens Agenda on my blog. Soon after, I got a message on a social media site. The message was from a man who’d left comments on my reviews before. He said that he’d been reading my blog for months, but he was unfollowing it because I had “given a positive review to a book that made homosexuality seem normal.” He told me to delete the review so that my blog didn’t lose any more followers. (For the record, my blog only lost one follower after I posted that review.)




I was a little shocked by the message. Like all blogs, mine had lost followers before, but no one had taken the time to tell me why. I promptly deleted his message and laughed it off, but then it started to bother me. The message felt like censorship. This random Internet stranger was pressuring me to alter my blog because he didn’t agree with it. That didn’t sit well with me. I have no problem with LGBT books, and I wasn't going to take down my review.

I wondered: If someone was trying to get a review removed from my ridiculous rinky-dink blog, then how much backlash do LGBT books face? If one person is trying to remove a review, then how many people are trying to get LGBT books removed from schools and libraries? Book banning is something that I’ve never understood. It’s fine if you don’t want to read a book, but is it really necessary to take the book away from everybody?

That message helped me realize that some groups of people—such as LGBT people—are still struggling to make their voices heard. That’s kind of devastating. I think everyone should be able to express themselves, even if you don’t agree with what they’re saying. I'm not part of any minority group, but I don't want to live in a world where only the majority group gets a voice.

It took a message from an angry Internet stranger to teach me that diversity in literature is about much more than just “finding yourself” in a book. It’s about giving a means of self-expression to people who have historically been silenced by society. It’s also about encouraging readers to see the world from someone else’s perspective. Diversity is never going away. No matter how much you rant and rave and try to censor book reviews, there will always be people who are different from you. Books are a way to help us make peace with our differences. The world would be a much nicer place if we all read diversely and tried a little harder to understand each other.

That’s why diversity in literature is important to me.


Random Spongebob meme because this discussion is getting too serious for this blog.





Let’s discuss: What does “diverse literature” mean to you? Do you ever read books written from perspectives that you don’t understand or don’t agree with? Why do diverse books matter to you?






Wednesday, July 13, 2016

Review: Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit – Jeanette Winterson


Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit – Jeanette Winterson


This is the story of Jeanette, adopted and brought up by her mother as one of God's elect. Zealous and passionate, she seems destined for life as a missionary, but then she falls for one of her converts. 
At sixteen, Jeanette decides to leave the church, her home and her family, for the young woman she loves. Innovative, punchy and tender, Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit is a few days’ ride into the bizarre outposts of religious excess and human obsession.


Review: Like most experimental stories, it took me a few days to decide if this one is terrible or brilliant. With experimental writing, there is always a fine line between “OMG this is awesome!” and “WTF is this?” Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit is part autobiography, part essay, and part fairytale. These different elements don’t always play well together, but ultimately, I decided that the book is brilliant.

Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit is based on the author’s life. The narrator, Jeanette, is adopted by an ultra-religious family and brought up to be a missionary. Her missionary plans are on-track until she falls in love with a girl. After a string of failed “cures” for her homosexuality, Jeanette leaves home at sixteen and strikes out on her own.

Jeanette Winterson hilariously explores the inconsistencies of the ultra-religious. Her mother wants to help people—which is a noble goal—but she doesn’t take the time to understand the people who she’s trying to help. For example, Jeanette’s mother starts the town’s first mission for “colored” people. When she cooks for the new converts, she dumps canned pineapple all over the food because she has the strange notion that pineapple is the only fruit that colored people eat. She has good intentions, but she severely lacks the ability to see the world from other people’s perspectives.

This misunderstanding extends to her daughter’s “unnatural passions.” When Jeanette fumbles her way into confessing that she isn’t attracted to men, her mother doesn’t try to understand her young daughter’s confusion. She just calls in an exorcist.

“As far as I was concerned men were something you had around the place, not particularly interesting, but quite harmless. I had never shown the slightest feeling for them, and apart from my never wearing a skirt, saw nothing else in common between us.” – Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit 
 
“ . . . to change something you do not understand is the true nature of evil.” – Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit

My favorite parts of the book are the scenes of Jeanette as a child in school. She is an outsider. As a child, she has a fascination with Hell, and she can’t understand why her teachers and fellow students don’t share her obsession. My favorite scene in the book is when Jeanette makes a needlework sampler with a Bible quote and an image of people burning in Hell. She demands that the teacher enter her work in a competition, even though the teacher doesn’t think it’s a good idea. I’m not religious, but I could totally relate to Jeanette in those scenes. I had a serious obsession with animals as a child. My first grade teacher even told me to stop talking about animals in class and to stop writing about them in my journal. Child-me was very confused about why it was wrong to find animals interesting.

“My needlework teacher suffered from a problem of vision. She recognised things according to expectation and environment. If you were in a particular place, you expected to see particular things. Sheep and hills, sea and fish; if there was an elephant in the supermarket, she'd either not see it at all, or call it Mrs. Jones and talk about fishcakes. But most likely, she'd do what most people do when confronted with something they don't understand. Panic.”  - Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit    

The overall tone of the book is pretty comical, but it’s still devastating when Jeanette loses her church family. Her religion keeps her from fitting in at school, and her homosexuality keeps her from fitting in at church. There aren’t many places in her world where she can be herself. This makes some of the secondary characters even more important. There are a few people in her life who take the time to understand her and offer help. She’s never completely alone, which is great.

Let’s talk about what didn’t work for me. I think I would have liked this book more if I was religious and British. Since I’m neither of those things, a lot of the references went over my head.

I also really dislike the fairytale parts of the story. I (kind of) understand why they’re in there. Jeanette is a very imaginative child, and the fairytales make the reader question the reliability of her narration. The fairytale characters’ quests also mirror Jeanette’s quest to accept herself. I understand the fairytales, but I didn’t care about them. Whenever the princes and princesses came up, I just groaned and waited impatiently to get back to the main storyline.

Other than the fairytales, I really like this book. If you’re interested in stories that are rich in symbolism, you need to read this one. I’d love to discuss the symbols, but this review is getting long, and I can sense your eyes glazing over with boredom. I’ll just say that I especially like how the author uses fruit to show conformity/rebellion/individuality/otherness. It’s clever and unexpected.

I can totally see why this quirky book is considered a modern classic. I’m glad I read it and will check out some of Jeanette Winterson’s other books.